…
Growing up, the only gay person I remember seeing out in the world was Ellen DeGeneres – I could tell by the haircut first and foremost. It was the kind that all the gay women I’d ever seen had – a small range of short styles, a kind of code saying to each other: yes, I am here, too. My mama watched Ellen frequently in those days; this was before the dancing, it’s cool to be kind, mass-giveaway, loved by all Ellen we know today. This Ellen of my childhood was unassuming, lightly funny, and maintained a candor careful not to demand too much of America.
Around this time, my mom also told me that Alicia Keys was reportedly bisexual. In my kid-mind, I assumed this meant she was gay. I had a little child’s crush on Alicia, the kind I didn’t understand yet was telling of something more about who I was. I played her song No One on my CD-player over and over again until my brother would beg me (or beat me) to stop. My mom being the slightly more feminine and more into feminine-ish women and my mama being slightly more fluid and into more androgynous-ish women, I’d plotted the perfect scenario. I thought that if my mama just met Ellen and my mom Alicia Keys, they’d each fall in love and be together. After all, there were barely any other gay people so the chances had to be pretty high, right? I day-dreamed about my glamorous life on the horizon – my mama with my step-mom Ellen DeGeneres and my mom with my other step-mom Alicia Keys. I’d have a fabulous life ahead of me.
Of course, my mama would never meet Ellen Degeneres and Alicia Keys later got married to a dude. I remember seeing a picture of her at some red carpet appearance, belly swollen deep in that last stage of pregnancy, her husband over her shoulder. I still remember the steep fall of my heart in my chest when I saw the glossy magazine image. Had my mother been wrong? I was something past anger, maybe indignant. There was the realization that deep down I’d known all along. These women were never going to save me. In fact, none of the women in my life would. I’d have to find another way.
…
Beyond Ellen, I didn’t know anyone else who was gay in our small cluster of towns, and my parents rarely sought out a queer community. My brother and I did, however, find ourselves subjected to an array of strange gatherings. Other gay women my mom had found on the internet (Craigslist) or through friends, always some get-together – a picnic, a Super Bowl party, or the most popular: the pot luck. Women, like and unlike my moms, packing fold-up lawn chairs, packing shareable snacks, and certainly packing other things.
These gatherings happened more frequently when I was very young, and then became a once a year or every couple of years kind of event. In my later years of high school, my mom took to hosting them for the Super Bowl. This was more an excuse to party than anything else. I’d look around at these women I’d watched throughout the years deteriorating into something I was terrified I’d one day become. I didn’t want to see myself in them.
To me, they’d all seemed caught somewhere in their 20’s – a second breath of life as out-gays in their middle age. Weekday night dyke dances at unassuming bars, jumping from dating one woman in the group to another, a kind of dating musical chairs, the thick smell of cigarettes and always, always nursing cheap beers clasped to the chest. They were marred by something perhaps inescapable. Some of them were serial u-haulers, some addicted to pain killers and muscle relaxers, some with other unnameable vices. These were the kinds of socials I’d watch sitting in the dark, gaze stuck between stairway railings and later I’d walk through, searching, both yearning for community and distancing myself. Looking at them, at this future, with shame and worst of all, pity.
Some of them had children, though most did not. Those who did, however, who I’d heard mentioned here and there throughout the years, were from previous marriages to men, none born to gay parents like I was. And we never met any of them. Aside from these rare occasions, we lived our daily lives alone with our otherness. The only time I ever thought there was another gay woman was a brief interlude with my elementary school gym teacher, late afternoon conversations between her and my mom in the hallways after school. Not long after I moved on to middle school, she was fired. Something suspect about the athleticism of women, teetering too far toward masculinity and away from “family values,” toward a threat to the innocence of neighborhood children. For years, I was terrified that my mom, a school nurse at the K-2nd grade school down the road would be next. I kept our secrets close.
…
Years later, I’d find myself at college parties, in clubs, music bumping, holding a drink against my collar bone, those slow moments between dancing where you find yourself not exactly with your body, where something you’d been keeping at bay catches up. Friends and strangers would often tell me I looked like I wasn’t really there, trying to make conversation as my fears, those earlier terrors, came back to me and said: you’re not there, yet.
How do we emerge, through the long, laborious act of becoming when we cannot see ourselves? When we cannot see beyond a simple and faltering survival?
Visibility is the seemingly victorious first step of the revolution. But visibility, without rights, without justice, without all of us free, is a dangerous mirage. We thirst for it, our throats drinking its image as salvation, not realizing we leave our own, tender necks to the merciless and beating sun on our doomed walk toward what we perceive as freedom – a duplicitous shimmering of air. When do we realize we have nothing to grab onto?
…
Recently I found an acoustic recording of No One. Alicia’s raspy voice has an assured devotion as she belts the familiar lyrics. But there’s something beneath it, a kind of grander affliction, an overcoming, an acceptance of one’s lot. This is what I’d been listening to all those years ago.
I still think Alicia’s a hottie.
you and me together / through the days and nights / I don’t worry ’cause everything’s gonna be alright
people keep talkin / they can say what they like / but all I know is everything’s gonna be alright
no one / no one / no one / could get in the way of what I’m feeling
no one / no one / no one / could get in the way of what I feel / for you
when they rain is pourin down / and my heart is hurtin / you will always be around / this I know for certain
I know people will try / try to divide / something so real / so till the end of time / I’m telling you that
no one / no one / no one / could get in the way of what I’m feeling
no one / no one / no one / could get in the way of what I feel / for you
I start the track again.